Systems Engineering FAQ

Answers by Robert Halligan FIE Aust CPEng IntPE(Aus).

How do we distinguish between excellent requirements and subpar requirements?

Share

How do we distinguish between excellent requirements and subpar requirements? There are many quality attributes that help us to define what a superior requirement looks like. They include:

  • Correctness: refers to an absence of errors of fact in the specified requirement
  • Completeness: for a requirement individually, refers to the inclusion of all necessary information such that if the requirement is satisfied, the need will also be satisfied; completeness – for requirements as a set, refers to the inclusion of sufficient requirements such that if the set is satisfied, the need will also be satisfied with only a small expected loss due to omissions
  • Consistency: requires that a requirement not be in conflict with any other requirement, nor be inconsistent internally
  • Clarity: requires that a requirement be readily understandable without semantic analysis
  • Non-ambiguity: requires that there be only one semantic interpretation of a requirement
  • Traceability: permits unambiguous requirements traceability in design and verification
  • Singularity: refers to a property whereby a requirement cannot sensibly be expressed as two or more requirements having different actors (subjects), actions (verbs) and/or objects of action
  • Feasibility: for a requirement, requires that some means exist whereby the requirement may be satisfied; feasibility – for a set of requirements, requires that some means exist whereby the requirements may be satisfied as a set 
  • Balance: a set of requirements, refers to the set being optimum, i.e., forming a part of an optimum solution to the higher (physical) level problem for which the item which is the subject of the requirements is a part of the solution
  • Freedom from product/process mix: absence of process in a product requirement (with exceptions)

These attributes and potential areas of defect in requirements are illustrative of the many topics that are covered in PPI’s Live-Online™ Requirements Analysis and Specification Writing 5-Day Course.

Share

Answered By

Systems engineering thought leader, consultant, trainer and coach, impacting people's lives on six continents.
Published 8 months ago

 

PPI_Logo_Symbol_Only.png
FREE Monthly SE Industry News?
Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top