Systems Engineering FAQ

Answers by Robert Halligan FIE Aust CPEng IntPE(Aus).

Are your overall comments related to ISO/IEC 15288: 2008 (in the FAQ section) still applicable to the 2015 revision, or have most of the shortcomings been addressed?


A. Thankfully, ISO/IEC/IEEE 15288:2015 is hugely better than ISO/IEC 15288:2008, so a lot of the comments on the 2008 standard do not apply. I would rate the 2015 standard overall at about 6.5/10, more good than bad, but still with some serious issues.

The main problem with the 2015 standard is the absence of recognition of the concept of a capability system, and the essential problem definition/problem solving relationship between requirements at a capability system level and requirements on solution elements including bits of technology (what the standard refers to as “system requirements”). The consequence is an implicit “then a miracle occurs” process, together with duplication of what are in reality identical processes of problem definition applied to different systems.


Answered By

Systems engineering thought leader, consultant, trainer and coach, impacting people's lives on six continents.
Published 1 year ago




Gain concepts and principles that will take your career to another level with PPI training!

FREE Monthly SE Industry News?

Why Recognition of Profit, not Imposition of Process, Will Ultimately Bring Systems Engineering Into Common Usage

What Factors Hold Back the Widespread Practice of Systems Engineering? Randall Iliff explores this fascinating question in the April 2023 issue of PPI SyEN. His perspective as a founding member of INCOSE and current PPI Principal Consultant offers unusual clarity regarding the challenges we face […]

Scroll to Top